child bipolar

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home

Forum

Newsletter

Chat

Book Store

FAQ

Medication

Parenting

Education

Support

Ask The Doctor

Treatment Guidelines

 

 

Discipline vs. Punishment for BP Kids

Discipline vs. Punnishment

Discipline for BPers, this is a dilema that we all have to face in raising our kids. Personally, I think the answer lies in the details.

Think *responsibility* instead *fault*.

Your child is not at fault for having BP, nor for having symptoms. No one would ever say he was *at fault* for vomiting if he had the stomach flu, and BP rages are very often like "brain barf".

However, each of us is *responsible* for our actions. As an adult, if I get the flu, although I am not at *fault*, I am still the one cleaning up any mess that I may make. I am a grown up and I am *responsible* for my messes, whatever the cause. I am trying to teach my boys that they are *responsible* for their illness. Being *responsible* includes not only careful behavior even when having symptoms, it includes taking care of things when they blow it, and it includes getting adequate rest, eating right, and taking their meds.

Instead of *punishment* think *discipline* or *training*

Punishment is punitive, it means the child is "paying" for his/her mistakes, and that's not really fair if the cause of the behavior was an illness. Our kids already pay too high of a cost in lost friendships, lost time, lost joy. *Discipline* or training is focused teaching better responses for the next time the problem situation comes around.

No kid (or adult for that matter) is going to be able to understand, process, and learn from *discipline* in the middle of a BP rage. If you wait til after the episode to talk about the problem, discuss alternatives, discuss restitution, then they can actually process what you are saying, rather than get into a huge confrontation that is fruitless. Sometimes if the child is very unstable, even between rages they are not able to process the *discipline*. Sometimes you have to wait for the meds to kick in, and that can be months, but eventually that time will come and you can begin to *discipline* you child so he/she can handle it out there in the adult world.

I love Ross Greens approach in the book Explosive Child. because it gives a concrete way for a parent to put these ideas into practice. It's important to remember to use "B" basket, as well as "A" and "C" though... or else all you are doing is ignoring the bad behavior, and that does not equip the child for his/her future.

It's hard to get the schools and others to understand that the process of being responsible for their own behavior is harder for our kids than for many others, and that often in has to be broken down into smaller chunks so it is more managable for them. It's a challenge as a parent to keep going and not grow weary when progrss in measured in milimeters and there are still kilometers yet to go.

For kids who are more stable, the book Parenting with Love and Logic by Foster Cline and Jim Fay can be very helpful in teaching them to function in the world, and also to help reduce the power struggles that can so easily develop with our kids.

Low Expressed Emotion is another important key in helping our kids. If we do not allow the illness to consume our lives and  do not become overly emotional at the conflicts, we provide a handhold to help our kids climb back into a "normal" life.

 

Curlywhirly (copyright 4/29/03)

 

 

THE FINE PRINT

The information on these web pages is the compilation of parents who are trying to help our kids and in the process help others as well. The information found on this site is intended solely for informational, educational and support purposes only.  There are no claims made of medical, legal, educational or other advice nor are there any guarantees implied. Do not make any medication or therapy changes, legal, educational or other decisions based on information found here without first consulting a professional who knows your child and family. Many websites, books and other sources are referenced for information, such reference does not imply endorsement.

Copyright © Crackerjack, Curlywhirly and Wickedpenmeister (2003)(2004)(2005)(2006)(2007) 

Site Map